Friday, September 17, 2010

The University and the Panopticon: Naturalizing "New" Governance Forms for Behavior Control Beyond Law

How do institutions with governance authority respond to  behaviors considered a problem, or a threat to the stable social order or social goals to be encouraged among its populations?  Traditionally, the responses of governance bodies would rely heavily on the conventional tools of government:  command and sanction.  In the form of law or regulation, coupled with enforcement and judicial procedure, these techniques have served the state and its subsidiary units with the principal methods for commanding subject populations and managing their behaviors.  But the last part of the 20th century saw the rise of new methods of governance--methods that bypassed law as inefficient and clumsy in favor of more subtle but comprehensive techniques.  These techniques are meant to operate on the bodies of the objects of governance, to weave a complex net of expectations, perspectives, and exposures,  and to naturalize cultures and expectations of exposure of even the most intimate activity.  The methodologies of these forms of governance were once methods of enforcing direct command through law.  

Today method provides the basis for substantive regulation without the need to declare the substance of the regulation itself.  In the form of  information  harvesting, publication and management--grounded on its utility for the development of judgment and the application of consequences--governance has come to be understood as a technique of management rather than of law.  It becomes most successful when it disappears into the background of cultural assumptions and expectations of the managed population.  As culture rather than as regulation, the state can also appear more benign, and the iron fist of control covered in the velvet of management that is self effected.   Observation, publication and judgment now serve as more effective instruments of governance than commands published in a register and administered haphazardly by an overwhelmed administrative and enforcement apparatus of the state.   And thus the panopticon has come to serve the state and related governance units, to extend the efficient control of subject populations in an efficient and more successful way.   For what can be more successful than a system of management and control in which the population to be controlled serve as their own wardens.   I have elsewhere tried to find order in this new approach to governance.  See, Larry Catá Backer,  Global Panopticism: States, Corporations and the Governance Effects of Monitoring Regimes. Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies  15(1):101-148 (2008).   

But this is all theory, and fairly opaque to those heavily invested in governance at the operational level.  An example might be useful to illustrate both the utility of this approach and its increasing importance as the preferred form of managing behavior.  A really useful example might focus on a subsidiary governance unit--a university, confronting a problem that requires behavior modification, cultural readjustment and control.  What follows is a short description of the way in which the modern panoptic approach to governance has become an important tool in the management of behavior among large masses of constituents and what that may suggest for governance by governments.  

The alcohol consumption habits of university students has become an issue of alarm to local, regional and national elites.  Alcohol consumption and abuse, especially, but not limited to those prohibited by law from its consumption has begun to absorb ever larger resources and universities, local, regional, state and national governments are confronted with behaviors that is judged detrimental to the welfare of the state (and the individual well being of those persons contributing to the crisis by  their behavior).  The traditional methods of control have proven ineffective--regulation by university officials, local governments, state and federal authorities have proven easy enough to evade .  Moreover, it is not clear that the larger culture shares precisely the same values and approaches to appropriate conduct that is the object of public and university regulators.  What is clear, however, is that the objections to the consequences of that behavior in terms of property damage, injury to individuals, the loss of future productive social elements, combined with a willingness of society to vest responsibility for these problems on universities, local, regional, state and federal governments (aided to some extent by the information media) has produced substantial pressure to force changes in behavior and manage the habits of a large target population.  Increasingly, universities have sought to center themselves within webs of panoptic techniques as a means of managing individuals and naturalizing a process of behavior control and modification that appears "natural" and "conventional".

The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAA) College Task Force reports have begun to point to the framework within which behavior can be governed, modified and internalized among a subject population.  See, e.g., NIAAA College Task Force Report, Proposed 3 in 1 Framework, or the Four Tiers Program. Many of these seek to integrate multi-government programs of education, control of the environment, targetted enforcement, prgrams of intervention, counseling and related support, institutionalization of objectives based outreach efforts and coordination with other programs targeting related behaviors (drug use or other activities deemed to have an antisocial component).

The Four Tier framework "The 4 Tiers organize some of the most commonly used prevention and intervention tactics according to the level of research that supports them."  Four Tiers, id.

Tier 1: Evidence of Effectiveness Among College Students

Strong research evidence (two or more favorable studies available) supports the strategies that follow. All strategies target individual problem, at-risk, or alcohol-dependent drinkers. Their efficacy as part of a campus-wide strategy has not been tested.
Strategy: Combining cognitive-behavioral skills with norms clarification and motivational enhancement interventions. Cognitive-behavioral skills training strives to change an individual's dysfunctional beliefs and thinking about the use of alcohol through activities such as altering expectancies about alcohol's effects, documenting daily alcohol consumption, and learning to manage stress. . . .
Norms or values clarification examines students' perceptions about the acceptability of abusive drinking behavior on campus and uses data to refute beliefs about the tolerance for this behavior as well as beliefs about the number of students who drink excessively and the amounts of alcohol they consume.
As its name implies, motivational enhancement is designed to stimulate students' intrinsic desire or motivation to change their behavior. Motivational enhancement strategies are based on the theory that individuals alone are responsible for changing their drinking behavior and complying with that decision (Miller et al., 1992). . . . 
Strategy: Offering brief motivational enhancement interventions. Students who receive brief (usually 45-minute), personalized motivational enhancement sessions, whether delivered individually or in small groups, reduce alcohol consumption. This strategy can also reduce negative consequences such as excessive drinking, driving after drinking, riding with an intoxicated driver, citations for traffic violations, and injuries. . . 
Strategy: Challenging alcohol expectancies. This strategy works by using a combination of information and experiential learning to alter students' expectations about the effects of alcohol so they understand that drinking does not necessarily produce many of the effects they anticipate such as sociability and sexual attractiveness. . . .

Tier 2: Evidence of Success With General Populations That Could Be Applied to College Environments

The Task Force recommends that college presidents, campus alcohol program planners, and student and community leaders explore the strategies listed below because they have been successful with similar populations, although they have not yet been comprehensively evaluated with college students. . . . 
Strategy: Increased enforcement of minimum drinking age laws (Toomey and Wagenaar, 2002; Wagenaar and Toomey, 2002). The minimum legal drinking age (MLDA) law is the most well-studied alcohol control policy. Compared to other programs aimed at youth in general, increasing the legal age for purchase and consumption of alcohol has been the most successful effort to date in reducing underage drinking and alcohol-related problems.. . . .
Strategy: Implementation, increased publicity, and enforcement of other laws to reduce alcohol-impaired driving. Injury and deaths caused by alcohol-impaired driving and related injuries and deaths can be reduced by lowering legal blood alcohol limits to .08 percent for adult drivers. . . .
Strategy: Restrictions on alcohol retail outlet density (Scribner et al., 1995; Gruenewald et al., 1993). Studies of the number of alcohol licenses or outlets per population size have found a relationship between the density of alcohol outlets, consumption, and related problems such as violence, other crime, and health problems. . . .
Strategy: Increased prices and excise taxes on alcoholic beverages. A substantial body of research has shown that higher alcoholic beverage prices or taxes are associated with lower levels of alcohol consumption and alcohol-related problems. . . .
Strategy: Responsible beverage service policies in social and commercial settings (Saltz and Stangetta, 1997; Holder et al., 1997b). Studies suggest that bartenders, waiters, and others in the hospitality industry would welcome written policies about responsible service of alcohol and training in how to implement them appropriately. Policies could include serving alcohol in standard sizes, limiting sales of pitchers, cutting off service of alcohol to intoxicated patrons, promoting alcohol-free drinks and food, and eliminating last-call announcements.. . . . 
Strategy: The formation of a campus and community coalition involving all major stakeholders may be critical to implement these strategies effectively. A number of comprehensive community efforts have been designed to reduce alcohol and other substance use and related negative consequences among underaged youth, including college students, and among adults. . . .

Tier 3: Evidence of Logical and Theoretical Promise, But Require More Comprehensive Evaluation

The Task Force recognizes that a number of popular strategies and policy suggestions make sense intuitively or have strong theoretical support. Many also raise researchable questions that may be crucial in reducing the consequences of college student drinking.. . . 
Strategy: Adopting campus-based policies and practices that appear to be capable of reducing high-risk alcohol use. The following activities are particularly appealing because straightforward and relatively brief evaluations should indicate whether they would be successful in reducing high-risk drinking on a particular campus.
  • Reinstating Friday classes and exams to reduce Thursday night partying; possibly scheduling Saturday morning classes.
     
  • Implementing alcohol-free, expanded late-night student activities.
     
  • Eliminating keg parties on campus where underage drinking is prevalent.
     
  • Establishing alcohol-free dormitories.
     
  • Employing older, salaried resident assistants or hiring adults to fulfill that role.
     
  • Further controlling or eliminating alcohol at sports events and prohibiting tailgating parties that model heavy alcohol use.
     
  • Refusing sponsorship gifts from the alcohol industry to avoid any perception that underage drinking is acceptable.
     
  • Banning alcohol on campus, including at faculty and alumni events.
Strategy: Increasing enforcement at campus-based events that promote excessive drinking (DeJong and Langenbahn, 1996; Gulland, 1994). Campus police can conduct random spot checks at events and parties on campus to ensure that alcohol service is monitored and that age identification is checked.. . . 
Strategy: Increasing publicity about and enforcement of underage drinking laws on campus and eliminating "mixed messages.". . . . Lax enforcement of State laws and local regulations on campus may send a "mixed message" to students about compliance with legally imposed drinking restrictions. Creative approaches are needed to test the feasibility of this strategy. . . .
Strategy: Consistently enforcing disciplinary actions associated with policy violations (DeJong and Langford, 2002). Inconsistent enforcement of alcohol-related rules may suggest to students that "rules are made to be broken.". . . . 
Strategy: Conducting marketing campaigns to correct student misperceptions about alcohol use . . . . . On the basis of the premise that students overestimate the amount of drinking that occurs among their peers and then fashion their own behavior to meet this perceived norm, many schools are now actively conducting "social norming" campaigns to correct many of these misperceptions. . . .
Strategy: Provision of "safe rides" programs (DeJong, 1995). Safe rides attempt to prevent drinking and driving by providing either free or low-cost transportation such as taxis or van shuttles from popular student venues or events to residence halls and other safe destinations.. ..
Strategy: Regulation of happy hours and sales . . . .  Happy hours and price promotions—such as two drinks for the price of one or women drink for free—are associated with higher consumption among both light and heavy drinkers. . . .
Strategy: Informing new students and their parents about alcohol policies and penalties before arrival and during orientation periods. There is some anecdotal evidence that experiences during the first 6 weeks of enrollment affect subsequent success during the freshman year. Because many students begin drinking heavily during this time, they may be unable to adapt appropriately to campus life. 

Tier 4: Evidence of Ineffectiveness

The Task Force recognizes that it is difficult or impossible to "prove" that a specific intervention approach is universally ineffective. . . . 
Strategy: Informational, knowledge-based, or values clarification interventions about alcohol and the problems related to its excessive use, when used alone . . . . This strategy is based on the assumption that college students excessively use alcohol because they lack knowledge or awareness of health risks and that an increase in knowledge would lead to a decrease in use.. . . .
Strategy: Providing blood alcohol content feedback to students. This strategy uses breath analysis tests to provide students accurate information on their BAC.. . .  Four Tiers Program, supra.
Pennsylvania State University recently announced a set of comprehensive multi-jurisdictional  and coordinated  strategies  to achieve desired governance objectives with respect to alcohol consumption.  University and local government officials have publicly outlined "a long list of strategies for addressing the issue including  making dorms alcohol free. . .  , notifying parents of students who receive any type of alcohol violation--rather than just serious or repeated violations, as in the past--and having a greater police presence in town.  Other efforts include encouraging faculty to make greater use of Friday class periods, getting rid of the week between finals and commencements and developing a method for requiring anyone taken out of a football game for alcoholism related problems to pass a breathalyzer to get into future games."  Anne Danahy, "University Leaders Get Updates on Booze Efforts, Endowment," Centre Daily Times, Sept. 18, 2010, at A-5.  Earlier in the month,Penn State had announced the implementation, on a trail basis, of a Brief Alcohol Screening and Intervention of College Students (BASICS) program.  See, Matt Scorzafave, PSU Implements BASICS Program, Daily Collegian, Sept. 3, 2010.  "BASICS is a one-on-one alcohol counseling program some Penn State students will be referred to when they get into legal trouble on- or off-campus. The program will focus on individual students' needs in order to change or improve their drinking habits in a personalized setting."  Id.  As explained in the public website describing the program,
The BASICS program consists of two one-hour sessions with a UHS staff member. During the first session, you will meet individually with a staff member and complete an on-line questionnaire. You will also be screened for alcohol abuse, depression, and anxiety. At the second session, you will discuss your questionnaire and personalized feedback with the staff member. You will receive a personalized feedback report that includes a comparison of your drinking to other Penn State students. You will explore ways to reduce future health, social, and legal risks. Additional sessions beyond the first two may be required for some students. Penn State Division of Student Affairs, University Health Services,  Brief Alcohol Screening and Intervention for College Students (BASICS).
This BASICS project is "based on a program created by Dr. Alan Marlatt (Director, Addictive Behaviors Research Center and Professor of Psychology at the University of Washington).  The BASICS program is one of the most effective alcohol education interventions with college students.  The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMSA) has recognized BASICS as an evidence-based model program."  Penn State Division of Student Affairs, University Health Services,  Brief Alcohol Screening and Intervention for College Students (BASICS).

The regulatory approaches to the governance objectives related to patterns of alcohol use by students provides an excellent window onto the way on which contemporary governance is effectuated.  These  efforts  suggest a very different approach to the management of behavior by public bodies than the traditional conventional approach grounded in law and rule fo law principles.  it suggests the privileging of method over form and of the therapeutic over the command structures of traditional governance.  These strategies move beyond the traditional law systems to one grounded in the naturalization of behavior on the bodies of the objects of regulation.   Let's see how programs that focus governance through these methods help shape the panoptic approach to managing behavior as a substitute to legislating standards.

1.  The focus of these methods is on the disciplining of the bodies of the objects of regulation.  Breathalyzer tests, examinations by physicians, observations by faculty, passersby, neighbors and the like form the  basis of control.  The focus is not on drinking so much as the consumer of drink.  Consumption opens the body to examination and thus examined, to consequences derived from that probing.  

2.  These regulatory systems are grounded in surveillance.  Surveillance provides a seamless and constant method for deriving information that can be used at leisure to make judgments and impose consequences.  Surveillance systems that are automatic, consequential and framed around the patterns of behavior of objects and their interactions with controlled institutions or institutions that cooperate. 
3.  Surveillance provides a means for extraterritorial applications of governance power.  Universities now routinely project power well beyond the property under their control.  Not just dormitories, but entertainment venues outside of campus now form part of the virtual governance space within which the university may impose and enforce behavior norms.  Extraterritoriality is increasingly used by states as well--from the use of public funds for investment in foreign states to control economic activity outside the national territory through private market interventions to the application of national law to the activities of actors abroad with connections int he regulating state.    Students now carry their status on their bodies as well as the regulatory matrix generated by the university.  University governance thus is transformed from a static device grounded in territory and control of space to a dynamic element that moves on the bodies of its subjects.  

4.  Extraterritoriality  provides a basis for the expansion of the breadth of traditional sanctions frameworks as multiple systems interact simultaneously on the bodies of their objects irrespective of territorial location.  First larger group`s of people are subject to sanctions.  For example, the hosts of liquor parties, servers at drinking establishments and others similarly situated may find themselves responsible for the consequences of drinking by students grounded both in local regulation and the trigger of student violation of university policy.  Second, sanctions may be increased in severity.  Third, a larger range of activities may trigger sanctions.

5.  Surveillance requires a set of mechanisms for the production of information that leverages governance power by exporting its use to the very objects of regulation.  As a consequence, these systems are focused on creating reward structures for private enforcement through whistle blowing.  Informants provide a important element of enforcement and also serve to better internalize the values  that trigger informing.   That reward structure can include protection from reprisal for informing on others. More important, reward structures that serve to reinforce the extent of privatization of enforcement may be grounded on forgiveness of a primary obligation--for example, informants or those who bring in violators for treatment to medical facility may receive forgiveness of their own violation (drinking) when they aid in enforcing regulation against others or aid in the prevention of injury by violators. 

6.  Privatization is not merely a function of whistle blowing and penalty bargaining.  Much of it may require support of privatized institutional approaches to behavioral modification.  Support of programs like Alcoholics Anonymous, campus ministries and projects by other campus groups that are meant to reinforce  approved behaviors may serve as key elements of a panoptic regulatory network. 

7.  But behavior modification requires multiple approaches to the control fo the body.  A critical additional approach  to behavior modification targets communication--the environment in which the object of regulation (the student) receives and evaluates information.  The instrumental use of communication is now understood as a critical component to behavior modifying regulatory campaigns.  Social marketing has become established as a key element of governance.  "Social marketing was "born" as a discipline in the 1970s, when Philip Kotler and Gerald Zaltman realized that the same marketing principles that were being used to sell products to consumers could be used to "sell" ideas, attitudes and behaviors." Nedra Kline Weinreich, What is Social Marketing, Weinreich Communications. 

8.  Surveillance can be understood as having both an active and passive  character.  The passive character--gathering and harvesting information--suggests an automatic and mechanical process.  But information does not sit inert--it is used to form judgments and inform consequences.  It has value in its distribution to actors outside as well as inside the university community where it is generated.  Even the process of determining what sort of information is to be collected, the manner of collection, and the meaning of that information, can substantially inform behavior.  The power of credit rating agencies to regulate behavior by their determination of what is to be rated is well known.  But transparency is also a powerful weapon.  Governments have long used transparency instrumentally--the publication in local newspapers of the names and pictures of offenders has long been used as a method of enforcement and control.  "Name and shame" tactics are at the heart of current transnational efforts at soft law regulation.   For the university, instrumental transparency can include reports to parents or guardians of violation, and information sharing with other regulatory institutions can have a powerful disciplining effect.  

9.  Transparency, information gathering, dissemination, social marketing, and privatization provide a foundation for more extensive programs of behavior modification targeting the bodies of offenders.  These reorientation and soft law behavior modification regimes  usually employ the language and techniques of the "factual" disciplines--science, psychology--as well as the invocation of moral systems.  Offenses can trigger mandatory interventions by psychological and social service providers attached to the university or local governments.  Disease models with social implications may be deployed to demonize the targeted behavior.  Conflation with other targeted behavior may be emphasized (alcohol and sexual assault for example).   And the bodies of offenders will be imprinted with impurity, through a discourse of deviance--alcohol consumption behaviors as medically, socially and morally deviant behaviors.

10.  Yet all of these techniques cannot be effective unless the objects of regulation become its principal enforcers. A university might therefore seek actively to recruit and reward target group elites to enforce its behavior modification governance framework.   Student leaders, the leadership of fraternity organizations, athletic team leaders and the like can be recruited and rewarded through the offer of participation in governance and the opening of employment and influence networks.  Their only obligation is to serve as an instrument of enforcement and social conditioning.  This is not merely privatization but an internalization through local elites.  The model is also well developed in public law, that of local elites in developing states recruited to serve the interests of developed states through the absorption of their values and their incorporation into the power networks of the developed state.  These local elites undertake the most intensive part of thew work of behavior modification, as subalterns on behalf of the dominant power. Faculty can be recruited as well.  Universities can consider changes in the faculty reward/obligations framework to induce changes in faculty interactions with students as part of the expectations of the profession.  Faculty can come to believe that an essential role of faculty includes observation, interaction and intervention in the lives of students who appear to violate alcohol conduct norms.  Surveillance, whistle blowing, transparency serve as enhancers of this role, as well as a means of evaluating faculty willingness to serve in this role. 

11.  These efforts are usually undertaken in tandem with traditional regulatory methods.  For universities and local government officials, that may mean a heightened resort to private law--for example nuisance laws, public urination and public disturbance law and an enhanced ability for individuals to use tort law.  

12.  These efforts at coordination serve as an opening to more intense communication between university and governmental efforts to modify the behavior of students.   That communication--structural coupling--that touches not merely on communication between governance systems, but efforts to coordinate and align points of contact, have significant governance potential within panoptioc governance frameworks.  University-government communication can produce efforts to harmonize and coordinate programs as well as joint venturing, the extent of which is meant to produce a seamless system of surveillance, intervention and conventional regulatory system that together  intensifies efforts to internalize conformity. Police coordination, extensions of jurisdiction between university and local community and similar measures crams harmonization down to the operational level.  But the panoptic elements is more clearly understood in the enforcement element of this cooperation.  Coordination produces an incentive towards anticipatory enforcement rather than an increase of traditional violation based enforcement.  It is likely that university-community police cooperation can produce programs  that permit intervention before a violation occurs--based on information gathered through surveillance and recorded patterns of prior conduct.  There is some social marketing about this approach, though even conventional governance has not produced consensus on the utility of this move.  See Minority Report.  Thus an open textured system of information harvesting and dissemination permits judgment that can support police action before the fact and thus reinforces the normative objectives of governance--avoidance of alcohol abuse.  

Thus, as the university in the United States confronts and seeks to solve the problem of alcohol consumption among its student population, it provides a window on the approaches to panoptic governance at lies at the heart of contemporary efforts to more effectively manage the behavior of individuals.  This "new" governance avoids reliance on the traditional forms of government--law, rule of law, command, and punish.  Instead it adopts the managerial forms of the therapeutic, deploys the techniques of self improvement and the power of information to not merely change behavior but to internalize those changes in a population that becomes the principal agents of its enforcement. These techniques have become particularly interesting to governments.  As systems of law and rule of law constrain government authority to act on its citizens, new techniques, more subtle and complex, may serve as an alternative means of achieving governance goals.    The perceived anti-social aspects of alcohol consumption may provide insights for th management of anti-social behaviors around the use of recreational drugs.  Certainly, the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy might provide support for local efforts by universities as a means of running governance experiments to develop more sophisticated panoptic systems for its own use on a national level.  See especially the ONDCP, 2010 National Strategy ("Endorsing a balance of prevention, treatment, and law enforcement, the Strategy calls for a 15-percent reduction in the rate of youth drug use over 5 years and similar reductions in chronic drug use and drug-related consequences such as drug deaths and drugged driving." 2010 National Strategy Executive Summary). The full strategy can be accessed here.

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Japanese Approaches to Corporate Social Responsibility (企業の社会的責任) and Global Human Rights--Between the Law-State and Corporate Culture

Currently, much important work is being undertaken at the international level that seeks to structure the parameters of behavior of economic enterprises in their relation to human rights.  Among the most important is the work of John Ruggie as the Special Representative of the United Nations Secretary General for Business and Human Rights, undertaken pursuant to a mandate of the U.N. Human Rights Council. On the framework, see, e.g., Larry Catá Backer, On the Evolution of the United Nations’ 'Protect-Respect-Remedy' Project: The State, the Corporation and Human Rights in a Global Governance Context (June 3, 2010). Santa Clara Journal of International Law, Vol. 9, No.1, 2010.
 
One of the most  potent insights of the current project to provide a comprehensive framework for approaching issues of corporate behavior and human rights is the recognition that corporate (and other business) actors are subject to multiple systems of behavior rules.  The two most important are those generated through public  bodies, principally states, and those generated through private actors, principally corporations and participants in markets.  The first is evidenced through law, regulation and the traditional and conventional expression of state authority.  The second is evidenced by the customary rules of behavior and expectations of those principal stakeholders in the business that operate within them and the markets within which they operate.   Both, together, evidence the promise and limits and multi-sources efforts to regulate corporate behavior by resort to conventionally available governance instruments, and the promise of governance techniques grounded in cultural translation.
 
Japan provides an interesting context for the application of these insights. The Japanese law-state provides little effective legal foundations for the structural imposition of corporate social responsibility behaviors in general, or the cultivation of sensitivity to the human rights consequences of corporate behavior more specifically.  The recently concluded study of the Japanese legal environment in this regard, conducted in the context of the SRSG's corporate law  tools project, amply evidences the limited value of the law-state to corporate behavior touching on business and human rights.  The corporate law tools project involved "corporate law firms . . . working with UN Special Representative John Ruggie to identify, in a series of 42 surveys, whether and how national corporate law principles and practices currently foster corporate cultures respectful of human rights.  The full list of participants and jurisdictions to be covered was announced in March 2009 (see announcement [PDF])."  U.N. Secretary General's Special Representative for Business and Human Rights, Corporate Law.

In the case of Japan, the Law firm of Cotty Vivant Marchisio & Lauzeral suggested the contours of the legal parameters framing corporate or business behavior in Japan. 
1. SETTING THE LEGAL LANDSCAPE
Japanese corporate law is mainly governed by the Company Act, which became effective in 2006. Human rights are mostly protected by specific provisions of the Japanese Constitution, as well as by many other domestic laws. Human rights enforcement is also fostered by Japan’s ratification of international human rights instruments as well as promotion of human rights through private initiatives, like the Keidanren’s Charter of Corporate Behavior.

2. REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
The Japanese jurisdiction belongs to a civil law tradition, and corporate law, like any other in Japan, is regulated at the national level. The main corporate/securities regulators are the Financial Services Agency (control of financial stability, liquidity of financial markets and corporate auditing), the Bank of Japan (monetary issues) and the Tokyo Stock Exchange (power of supervision of transactions on the market).

3. INCORPORATION AND LISTING
Despite the existence of the concepts of “limited liability” and “separate legal personality”, especially in the Joint Stock Corporations (the most frequent form of company in Japan), such corporations are not required to recognize any duty to society, except for the respect of legality in their activities. Yet, they are allowed to consider such duties, which are essential criteria in the companies’ assessment by the two Japanese responsible investment indexes. The participation of corporations to these indexes is mostly non voluntary, as most listed companies are screening based primarily on public information on websites and annual reports. However, a company may submit additional information which will be incorporated in the decision making process.

4. DIRECTORS’ DUTIES
Directors’ duties are mainly owed to the corporation itself, although directors may be, to a certain extent, liable to third parties. Their legal duties clearly provide that directors shall avoid legal risk and damage to the company’s reputation. Failing to uphold such duties may have consequences regarding civil or even criminal liability. Directors are not specifically required to consider the impact of the company’s (or its subsidiaries’) activity on non-shareholders, whether it is inside or outside the Japanese jurisdiction. However, directors may be required to consider such impact as a result of their duties to avoid legal risk and damage to the company, of certain health and safety laws, or certain environmental laws, and when the corporation is in insolvency proceedings.
 
5. REPORTING
Reporting and disclosure requirements of Japanese companies do not include any obligation to disclose the impacts of their operation (or of the action of subsidiaries, suppliers, and other business partners) on non-shareholders, whether occurring inside or outside the jurisdiction (especially human rights impacts), as long as such impacts are not significant for the company. Should such be the case however, it would become mandatory to disclose such information for the public interest or the protection of investors. In addition, many Japanese corporations boast voluntary publication of Corporate Social Responsibility reports.
 
6. STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT
There is no particular restriction on circulating shareholders proposals dealing with impacts on non-shareholders and the possibility for non-shareholders to address companies’ general meetings is subject to the articles of incorporation. Many Japanese institutional investors consider the impact of the company on human rights in their investment strategies.
 
7. OTHER ISSUES OF CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
Keidanren), as well as individual charters adopted voluntarily by many Japanese corporations, has a key impact on promoting good corporate governance practices In addition, based on the general prohibition of discrimination because of race, creed, sex, social status or family origin in the Japanese Constitution, there can be no discrimination between members of the board for any gender, racial or ethnic reason.  Cotty Vivant Marchisio & Lauzeral, Corporate Law Tools Project--Japan (Sept. 2009) (Executive Summary).
The Japanese example is not much different in scope or effect from those of other states examined.  For a report on the results of the corporate law tools project, see "Overarching Trends and Observations" [PDF] - Based on the participating firms’ surveys of over 40 individual jurisdictions, this report was published by the Special Representative in July 2010.  See also Prof. Ruggie's commentary on the report, "Review Links Corporate and Securities Law and Human Rights", 27 Jul 2010.

Yet this is not necessarily a bad thing.  For the Japanese law-state has not impeded corporate efforts to embrace either corporate social responsibility frameworks in general or sensitivity to the human rights affecting aspects of their operations more specifically. 
The initiative of Nippon Keidanren, the Japanese Business Federation, which adopted the Charter of Corporate Behavior in 1991, is the most important example of “industry-driven” Corporate Social Responsibility policies in Japan . . . . The last version of this Charter dates back to May 18, 2004 and asserts that companies should “take social responsibility flexibly and voluntarily”. Agreeing that corporations need to “enhance their social significance and value”, the Keidanren has written ten principles in its Charter, some of them being directly related to human rights. Although this Charter is a voluntary initiative of the Nippon Keidanren15 and is not legally binding, the Charter has had significant results in terms of influencing company behavior. Cotty Vivant Marchisio & Lauzeral, Corporate Law Tools Project--Japan (Sept. 2009) (Paragraph 22.1).
Indeed, what clearly emerges in a willingness of Japanese corporations to fill in the gaps in the area of corporate behavior through their own efforts.  This is the essence of the Nippon Keidanren's Charter of Corporate Behavior.
 
Yet it would be a mistake to suggest that these initiatives proceed  principally from the law-state, or from the framing efforts of public authorities of law.  Rather, the source of these efforts.  My research assistant Shing Kit Wong (Penn State School of International Affairs, expected '12) has begun to explore  the socio-cultural bases of corporate governance touching on issues understood as corporate social responsibility and the human rights impacts of corporate behavior, "Japanese Thought on Corporate Social Responsibility."     His preliminary report suggests the context within which these issues are being developed and the perspective from which they emerge.
 
_________
 
Japanese thought on Corporate Social Responsibility
Shing Kit Wong
Master of International Affairs Candidate
Introduction

The history of corporate social responsibility (企業の社会的責任) in Japan can be traced back to the Edo period, which main idea was honesty in operation, and contribution to the society. It also structuralized the morality and harmony among merchant, customer and the society. Corporate social responsibility was brought to attention in 1970s due to a large amount of corporate scandals, such as corruptions and environmental pollutions, as a “byproduct” of the rapid economic growth in the 1960s. The public lost confidence in corporations. As a result, corporate social responsibility was widely promoted in order to retrieve public confidence to corporations. Thus, corporate social responsibility in Japan is strongly related to corporate philanthropy (社会貢献) and sustainable development (持続的発展. In the Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) Advisory Committee interim report by the Japanese Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry in 2004, it summarized six basis points of corporate social responsibility:
1. CSR is fulfilled through interaction with stakeholders.
2. CSR is not only remained in the outside communication of corporate, but also include the organizational system inside the corporate.
3. Observance of the law is the foundation of all business activity. Including environmental protection, respect human right, social contribution, etc.
4. CSR includes national and regional sense of value, culture, economy, and social matter.
5. Since the content of CSR is extensive and closely related to business, the effort of voluntary and tact is very important.
6. The most important effort to receive trust is to disclose the information including comment from stakeholders and explain the responsibility to stakeholders.
From these six basis points, Japanese corporate social responsibility can be viewed in three main areas: environmental protection (sustainable development) and corporate philanthropy, responsibility toward customer, and human right.

Background

Japanese corporate responsibility mainly focused on the principle of national interest (国益主義), in which the national goal is strongly emphasized in the strength of the military, before World War II. After the war, the goal was not suitable upon the defeat of the war. The primary aims of government were in the social welfare and rebuild of the country, and corporate responsibility had tied up with economy reconstruction. Since the beginning of 1950s, the Japanese economy grew rapidly. However, corporate scandals such as corruptions and pollutions in the society also became the byproduct of the economic growth. The public lost confidence toward corporations, and stated that corporations were naturally inherited evil (企業性悪説). In order to enhance the images of corporations and regain the public confidence, corporate social responsibility had its first boom in the 1970s. Corporations which destroyed the environment were strongly criticized, and the benefit received from business activities should return to the society. In the 1980s, the society and life of the citizens were benefited in the economical aspect, but the quality of the citizens’ life was not an improvement because of long working hours, resulted in various social issues. Toward the end of 1980s, the period of economic bubble, corporate had extra funding for activities such as art festivals and cultural festivals fore contributing to the society. Yet, some had criticized that such corporate philanthropy was only a cover up of the real social issues. During the depression in the 1990s, corporations had an operating philosophy of symbiosis with the society ( 社会との共生), which corporate philanthropy toward the society was one of the existing purposes. Corporations with such operating philosophy and the society sought a long term perspective in recovering the economy and living standard of the citizen. In the 2000s, global environmental issue became a popular topic, and also became a significant concern in corporate social responsibility.

Environmental protection (sustainable development) and corporate philanthropy

Japanese economy started growing rapidly after the Occupational period in the 1950s. The majority of the investments were in electric power, coal, iron, steel, and chemical fertilizers. The economy not only recovered the lost resulted by the war but also surpassed the growth rates of the pre-war period. Between 1953 and 1965, Japanese GDP expanded more than 9% per year. In 1965, the nominal GDP in Japan was estimated at over $91 billion, and over 170 billion by the end of the decade. However, massive pollution was also produced during the economy growth period. Furthermore, the oil crisis in 1973 affected the industrial production and caused severe price inflation. Most corporations were severely criticized, and had a negative reputation in the society. It was realized that the morality of corporate was gone and that corporations were purely greedy and evil. In order to enhance the image of corporations and restore a harmonized society, corporations promoted numerous environmental protection projects and reimbursed to the society in the 1980 during the second growth of the economy. 

The traditional philosophy in business is to from a harmonized society, in which emphasize the relations between merchant and customer, Japan and the world, and human being and nature. In 1987, Our Common Future was published from the United Nations World Commission on Environment and Development. Its targets were multilateralism and the search for a sustainable development, a pattern of resource usage that intends to meet human needs while preserving the environment, so that these needs can be met not only in the present, but also for future generations. In another word, it is a development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. This ideology had been engraved in the corporate social responsibility ever since.

The management principles of Mitsui Group, one of the largest conglomerates in Japan and traded companies in the world, are mainly revolved around environmental protection and corporate philanthropy. The corporate mission philosophy is contributing to the Earth, where it is filled with people’s dreams of the future (大切な地球と、そこに住む人びとの夢溢れる未来作りに貢献します) . In order to achieve this magnificent mission, Mitsui intended to increase the total value of the enterprise in economic, environmental, and management through profession and social action to achieve sustainability and a harmonized economic environment. Under this principle, Mitsui is working on a global scale, dealing with the problems of global warming, risk management systems including environmental conservation and pollution prevention, and promoting environmental friendly technology and environmental responsibility. Mitsui has deployed a variety of environment-related businesses in the world to administrate their Principles of Environmental Policy to the environmental industry including renewable energy projects, emission projects, recycling business, modal railway business, forestation, etc. For instance, Mitsui is actively involved in solar power generation, wind power generation, and biomass power generation projects. While carbon dioxide emissions are said to cause global warming, Mitsui participates in production and sales of carbon-neutral bio-energy. Through environmental protection, the greenhouse gases and industrial waste had been reduced. In addition, such activities created new markets in the society. All the establishment of companies, plant construction, and assistance to recycling partners provided a securing local employment and strengthened the economy. The corporate social responsibility principle of Mitsui Group highly reflects the traditional philosophy in business in Japan.
 
Responsibility toward customer
 
Japanese corporate social responsibility toward customer focuses on providing excellent service and product to the consumer. There are five major elements consisted in the product providing to the consumer: high quality, function, safety, environmental friendly, and cost. Japanese corporate believes that the central part of customer’s satisfaction is the performance of product and service in which consumer needs are met. This includes the functions and safety of the products and its reliability. The function of the product is a property of acting on how the product and service satisfy the consumer. It would focus on the consumer’s needs and the limitation of their usage of product and service. For instance, products would be manufactured with the consideration of the usage of people with disabilities. In addition, the usage of the product and service must avoid potential harm to the consumer and damaging of the product, as well as the harmony of the society. The product and service has to be environmentally friendly in order to reduce the impact on biological and ecological destruction for the future generations. The price of the product and service also has to be reasonable to the consumer. It is necessary supply product and service with the consideration of those factors in order to enhance business value and sustainable society. In order to fulfill such factors, the products are strictly tested to achieve the ISO 9241-11, which deals with the extent to a product that can be used by specified users to achieve specified goals with effectiveness, efficiency and satisfaction in a specified
context of usage. The products would then be examined by non-profit organization such as ISO.

Furthermore, the relationship between consumers and corporate also fall under the ideology from the Consumers International. The CI advocated eight consumers’ rights and five consumer’s responsibilities.
 
The eight consumer’s rights are as follow:
1. The Right to Satisfaction of Basic Needs; which emphasize the right to get the necessary product and service to ensure survival
2. The Right to Safety; which emphasize the protection from product and service that is dangerous to life and health 3. The Right to be Informed; which emphasize the right to receive honest
information and advertisement necessary for decision making
4. The Right to Choose; which emphasize the right to choose the precise product and service from quality assurance to the satisfaction offered at competitive prices
5. The Right to be Heard; which emphasize the right to represent consumer interests in the development of product and service
6. The Right to Redress; which emphasize the right to appeal for poor service, mistakes and receive compensation
7. The Right to Consumer Education; which emphasize the right to obtain knowledge and skills required to select product and service
8. The Right to a Healthy Environment; which emphasize the right to live and work in an environment without fear and danger for the current and future generations
Following is the five consumer’s responsibilities:
1. Critical Awareness: consumers have the responsibility of becoming a sensitive awareness and quality for the price of goods and services
2. Action and Involvement: consumers have the responsibility to act and
to obtain a fair deal
3. Social Responsibility: realize the responsibility of the consumption behavior and the influence of others, especially the effect to the weak
4. Ecological Responsibility: consumers have the responsibility for understanding the environmental impact of their consumption behavior
5. Solidarity: consumers have the responsibility to defend the interests of consumers
The essence on such responsibility of providing excellent service and high quality product to customer might have been corrupted in this competitive market. In 2009 to 2010, Toyota Motor recalled approximately nine million vehicles for the pedal entrapment/floor mat problem and accelerator pedal problem worldwide, and the majority of the recall being in the United States. Such crisis resulted in an approximately 2 billion loss in sales worldwide for Toyota Motor Corporation. The president of the Toyota Motor, Mr. Aiko Toyoda, had pointed out this phenomenon in the competitive market, and affected the quality of the product at the testimony in Washington D.C. in February 2010. Mr. Toyoda stated that the corporation’s priority has traditionally been: First—Safety, Second—Quality and Third—Volume, and that those priorities became confused in this competitive market. The corporations pursued growth over developing speed of the organization, but yet, resulted in the safety issues of the vehicles. In addressing to the crisis, Mr. Toyoda shared the philosophy of Toyota’s quality control and the seriousness Toyota Motor Corporation took on quality and safety of its vehicles. He also explained that at the corporation, the key to making quality products is to develop quality people, and that each employee should thinks about what should be done in making improvements continuously, and thus, making even better vehicles. Under the philosophy of continuous improvements(改善), Toyota Motor Corporation aims to continue offering even better products for society. Mr. Toyoda had personally placed the highest priority on improving quality over quantity, and that under his leadership, he had reaffirmed Toyota’s values in such principle. In order to achieve safety and high quality products, members of the management team would actually drive the vehicles, and that they would check for themselves where the problem lies. He believed that only by examining the problems on site can ensure the management team to make decisions from the customer perspective. At the end of Mr. Toyoda’s statement, he committed to the customers with his reputation:
“My name is on every car. You have my personal commitment that Toyota will work vigorously and unceasingly to restore the trust of our customers.”
Although the malignant competition in the market resulted in such crisis, Mr. Toyoda, representing the Toyota Motor Corporation, reaffirmed the philosophy of the corporate social responsibility toward customer of placing safety and quality the highest on the list of priorities. Such philosophy revolves around the principle corporate social responsibility toward customer, as well as the philosophy of social contribution.

Human Right
Human right in the Japanese society is highly respected. In the Constitution of Japan Article 97, it states:
“The fundamental human rights by this Constitution guaranteed to the people of Japan are fruits of the age-old struggle of man to be free; they have survived the many exacting tests for durability and are conferred upon this and future generations in trust, to be held for all time inviolate.”
The Labor Law in Japan is constructed under the principle of this article. The Labor Standard Act, Trade Union Law, and the Labor Relations Adjustment Act are the three main Labor Laws (労働三法) in Japan. The purposes of the Trade Union Law and Labor Relations Adjustment Act are to improve the status of workers by promoting fairness in negotiations with employers. They are also to prevent labor disputation with employers, and thus, maintaining industrial peace. On the other hand, the Labor Standard Act ensures a safe and healthy working environment, fair wages, annual paid vacation, maternal leave, accident compensation, and prevents long working hours, child labor, discrimination of all kind, and force labor. In Mitsubishi Corporate, the corporate social responsibility toward human and labor right is very much referring to the principle of the Labor Laws. Being one of the Mitsubishi Corporate branches, the philosophy of Mitsubishi Paper Mills Limited is creating a working environment with the respecting the humanity of employees, and safety being the highest priority in workplace in order to demonstrate the full potential of each employee. Such philosophy is empowered by the guideline of respecting human right, preventing discrimination of all kind, ensuring a health and safe working environment, and compliance to the Labor Laws. Mitsubishi Paper Mills promoted employment for the disabled and the elderly, and in the consideration of work-life balance, the company introduced a time management technology to prevent long working hour and overworked.
 
However in this competitive market, whether the principle of the corporate social responsibility toward human right could be practice is questionable. Due to the contribution from the corporate toward the society, the issues of human right were always overlooked. In order to maximize profit, benefit of the labor always becomes the first to reduce, and that government official would sometimes be ignorant about the human right issues. Instead, diligence and loyalty toward the corporate and society became a social norm, and that employees were “willing to” work longer hours. Furthermore, for transnational corporate, whether the principle of corporate social responsibility toward human right applies on foreign soil is also remain questionable. In the summer of 2010, Chinese workers in the Honda Motor manufacturing plants throughout China went on strike because of unfair wages. The Chinese labors insisted on “same work, same pay” with the Japanese labors, yet the wage of a Japanese technical specialist (50000 yuen) in Chinese manufacturing plant was 50 times more than a female Chinese worker (1000 yuen). The incident ended with a raise of wages for the Chinese labor, but the wage difference between Chinese labor and other labor in South Asia is still large. Although there are many unanalyzed elements in the incident, corporate social responsibility in human right tend to be measured by different rulers.
 
Conclusion
 
The history of corporate social responsibility in Japan can be traced back in the Edo period, which main idea was honesty in operation, and contribution to the society. Corporate social responsibility became essential due to the negative image of corporations during the rapidly economy growth in the after the Occupational period. Japanese corporate social responsibility always revolve around Environmental protection, sustainable development and corporate philanthropy since the Japanese traditional philosophy in business is to from a harmonized society with the emphasis in the relations between merchant and customer, Japan and the world, and human being and nature. Japanese corporate social responsibility toward customer focuses heavily on providing excellent service and product to the consumer, and such produce has to be high quality and safe to the consumer. Japanese corporations respect human right, in which harmony is created between labor and employer in order to achieve economical efficiency. However, in the competitive market, labor’s human rights were sometimes overlooked, and that social norm was created to override such abuse. On the other hand, Japanese transnational corporations tend to have different measures of human right for labor outside of Japan.

References:

萩原愛一「企業の社会的責任」2005.3.24

岡野麻里「日本企業の社会貢献活動による途上国支援の可能性と限界」2006.3

佐藤大樹「総合商社の環境CSR」

嶋野将太「企業の消費者に対する社会的責任」

古内 翔「CSRと労働・人権問題」

猪口 孝「現代国際政治と日本―パールハーバー50 年の日本外交」P.122-26

経済産業省『企業の社会的責任(CSR)に関する懇談会中間報告書』2004.4.28
 

___________

Mr.Wong's analysis suggests a set of preliminary insights add an important layer of understanding to the principally law based analysis that is the traditional focus of corporate social responsibility and the human rights impacts of corporate behavior.  Wong suggests both an approach to the issue (social harmony) and its expression throughout the social order--from family, to group, to corporate entity, to society, to state--that substantially impacts both the approach to judging the actions of key stakeholders and determining the place (within the social and legal environments) in which such activity might best to located.    
 
More importantly, Mr. Wong reminds us of the impact of place within a transnational analysis of corporate behavior.   Corporate behavior can be as much a function of the place where it is to be effected as it is grounded in a set of uniform norms.  It appears easy enough for corporations to apply corporate social responsibility and human rights impact analysis differently to home state and host state stakeholders.  A state-law system may be indifferent to that result, but the aggregate behavior may substantially reduce the value of human rights based behavior norms differentially applied. 

National People of Color Conference Concludes

The Third National People of Color Conference, Our Country Our World in a "Post-Racial" Era,  has just concluded.  Hosted superbly by Seton Hall Law School and organized by Professor Solangel Maldonado and the National Steering Committee, the conference brought together over five hundred law and law related academics.  The Conference had as its goal to 

address critical national and global issues through the lens of legal scholarship that explicitly and implicitly examines contemporary racial context. It will feature panels on the “war on terror,” urban revitalization, criminal law, health care, education, immigration, human trafficking, voting rights, international and comparative law, judicial nominations, environmental justice, and corporate responsibility, among others. It will also include a Junior Faculty and Development Workshop and a Pipeline Program for lawyers interested in entering the legal academy. A media plenary session will explore the meaning of a “post-racial” society and its relevance to legal scholarship and teaching.  Third National People of Color Conference, Our Country Our World in a "Post-Racial" Era?, Homepage.
Speakers included, 
Honorable Cory Booker, Mayor of Newark, New Jersey
Kathleen Martinez, Assistant Secretary of Labor for Disability Employment
Professor Derrick Bell, Visiting Professor at New York University School of Law
The Honorable Joseph A. Greenaway, U.S. Court of Appeals, Third Circuit
Gay McDougall, United Nations Independent Expert on Minority Issues
Keith Harper, former Appellate Justice of the Mashantucket Pequot Tribal Nation

The Reverend Jesse L. Jackson, Sr. was a special guest speaker on Friday, September 10, 2010. The program was broad and may be accessed here.     



My own paper, Not Their Master's Tools: Transnational Corporate Governance and Anti-Subordination Strategies Among Communities of Color, was presented as part of a panel entitled: Critical Race Corporate Governance in a Domestic and Transnational Environment. The abstract follows:
Paper Abstract: That political communities are vertically ordered is well known, as is the resulting structure of exploitation and subordination. This vertical ordering has been reproduced in the elaboration of a global system of economic organization understood as globalization. As a consequence, economic, social, cultural and religious communities, like the states with which they interact, also tend to replicate this pattern of organization. The ideology of subordination is deeply embedded in global culture; it is exploited as effectively by communities of color against each other as it is deployed against communities of color by developed states. Yet that ideology might also be characterized as irrational. It can be argued that at the transnational level, corporations have failed to act rationally with respect to a global population that is overwhelmingly composed of communities of color, communities of color that have been traditionally exploited or ignored by both economic entities and the governments seeking to impose global order on transnational actors and markets. Political efforts to reduce discrimination and subordination at the global level have been discouraging. But emerging systems of global soft law may provide a basis for attaining a greater measure of racial and ethnic justice. This paper examines how international civil society actors are beginning to use instruments of soft law corporate governance to attack discrimination and subordination of communities of color by economic actors and others a variety of contexts. The paper’s thesis follows: the power to affect the relationships between communities of color and global economic actors may prove a more powerful force for change than those targeting traditional nation-states or the global state-law system.
The manuscript will be posted to the Social Science Research Network in a few days.

Monday, September 06, 2010

On the Third Japan-China High Level Economic Dialogue

It is sometimes useful to compare how two trading partners exploit news of and the results of symbolically important meetings. To that end, the insights from Akira Kurosawa's film Rashomon (羅生門) might prove useful. 
 The film depicts the rape of a woman and the murder of her samurai husband, through the widely differing accounts of four witnesses, including the bandit/rapist, the wife, the dead man speaking through a medium (Fumiko Honma), and lastly the narrator, the one witness that seems the most objective and least biased. While the stories are mutually contradictory only the final version is unmotivated by other factors. Accepting the final version as the truth (the now common technique of film and TV of only explaining the truth last was not a universal approach at that time) explains why in each other version "the truth" was worse than admitting to the killing, and it is precisely this assessment which gives the film its power, and this theme which is echoed in other works.  Rashomon (1950).

To that end it is interesting to see how the Chinese and Japanese sides reconstructed the substance and focus of the meetings and agreements that were managed as part of the Third Japan-China High Level Economic Dialog. While the description by each side is useful, both sides acquire an added dimension when considered side by side. Each reveals more about the storyteller than they might about the event. But if this is true, who will play the role of the "narrator/witness"?

I start with the story of the event as told by Chinese media.  I then reproduce the Japanese version of events.

__________

 Chinese Vice Premier Wang Qishan (R) shakes hands with Japanese Foreign Minister Katsuya Okada in Beijing, capital of China, Aug. 28, 2010. Wang Qishan and Katsuya Okada co-chaired the third China-Japan high-level economic dialogue here Saturday. (Xinhua/Rao Aimin)

BEIJING, Aug. 28 (Xinhua) -- Chinese Vice Premier Wang Qishan said here Saturday that bilateral trade between China and Japan has recovered and exceeded the level before the financial crisis.
Wang made the remarks at the opening of the third China-Japan high-level economic dialogue, which he chaired with Japanese Foreign Minister Okada Katsuya.
At the dialogue, the two sides will hold discussions on promoting the economic recovery and bilateral cooperation as well as cooperation at the regional and global level.
The two economies are highly interdependent, said Wang, adding mutual benefit and win-win cooperation were at the core of Sino-Japanese economic relations.
The two countries had maintained sound cooperation in energy-saving, environment protection, food safety, product quality and the construction of China-Japan-ROK Free Trade Area, he said.
It was the first economic dialogue held between Japan and China since the Democratic Party of Japan took office, said Katsuya.
After 30 years of development, China has become Japan's largest export market and the preferred overseas investment destination for Japanese manufacturing for 21 consecutive years.
China is undergoing rapid industrialization and urbanization and has huge market potential, said Wang.
He said China would firmly stick to the policy of opening up and create a good environment for foreign-owned enterprises.
Increasing mutual understanding and trust are the preconditions of bilateral cooperation, Wang said, adding the dialogue showed the increasing maturity of the Sino-Japanese economic relations.
The dialogue, jointly launched by Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao and then Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, was first convened in 2007 in Beijing and the second meeting was held in 2009 in Tokyo.  Third China-Japan economic dialogue kicks off in Beijing, English Xinhuanet.com, Aug. 28, 2010.

__________

If the Chinese version was breezy and designed to emphasize the connection between the meeting and the "Go Global" policies of the Chinese State,  the Japanese version presents a very different tone and perspective.  Here the approach is technocratic and detail oriented.  It suggests not the larger picture but a number of small victories that the Japanese negotiators raised during the course of the engagement.  But that approach also suggests a very great difference in perspective--big picture overall goal oriented on the Chinese side, technocratic and detail structure oriented on the Japanese side.  that imbalance is bound to produce "victories" for both sides, but of such different scope and effect that they distort the overall direction and effect of the emerging relationship structure between these two wary partners, former enemies and objects of mutual demonization among their respective masses.  

__________ 

Overview of the Third Japan-China High-Level Economic Dialogue
August 28, 2010







The Third Japan-China High-Level Economic Dialogue was held in Beijing on August 28.

Participants from the Japanese side include nine ministers/vice ministers: Mr. Katsuya Okada, Minister for Foreign Affairs (Chair); Mr. Yoshihiko Noda, Minister of Finance; Mr. Masahiko Yamada, Minister of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries; Mr. Masayuki Naoshima, Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry; Mr. Sakihito Ozawa, Minister of the Environment; Dr. Shozaburo Jimi, Minister of State for Financial Services; Mr. Hideo Hiraoka, Senior Vice Minister for Economic and Fiscal Policy; Mr. Masamitsu Naito, Senior Vice Minister of Internal Affairs and Communications; and Mr. Taizo Mikatsuki, Senior Vice Minister of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism.



Participants from the Chinese side include: Mr. Wang Qishan, Vice Premier of the State Council (Chair); eight minister-level officials - Dr. Yang Jiechi, Minister of Foreign Affairs; Mr. Zhang Ping, Chairman of National Development and Reform Commission; Mr. Xie Xuren, Minister of Finance; Dr. Chen Deming, Minister of Commerce; Mr. Li Yizhong, Minister of Industry and Information Technology; Mr. Zhou Shengxian, Minister of Environmental Protection; Mr. Han Changfu, Minister of Agriculture; and Dr. Zhi Shuping, Minister of General Administration of Quality Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine; and four deputy minister-level officials - Mr. Bi Jingquan, Deputy Secretary-General of the State Council; Mr. Chen Jian, Vice Minister of Commerce; Dr. Yi Gang, Deputy Governor of the People's Bank of China; and Dr. Zhang Yongli, Deputy Director of the State Forestry Administration.



The following is an overview of the dialogue and its major outcomes:
1. Overview
(1) In light of the growing interdependence of Japanese and Chinese economic relations and their increasing importance in the regional and global economies, the economic ministers of both countries deepened their mutual understanding by engaging in candid discussions on addressing the recovery of the world economy, enhancing the mutually beneficial cooperation between Japan and China and its challenges, as well as strengthening global and regional cooperation and their challenges. The ministers agreed on many fronts pertaining to the specific ways and means of cooperation.
(2) The two sides welcomed the fact that this dialogue strengthened the economic dimensions of their "Mutually Beneficial Relationship based on Common Strategic Interests." The two sides confirmed to continue advancing efforts to further enhance and materialize the mutually beneficial relationship. Furthermore, the two sides agreed to fulfill important responsibilities in the region and the international community.
2. Addressing the recovery of the world economy

The two countries, located in Asia--the "growth center" of the world and accounting for approximately 17% of the world's total GDP, shared the view to make a significant contribution to the recovery of the world economy by mutually achieving stable and sustainable economic growth. Japan will implement its New Growth Strategy and Fiscal Management Strategy under the strong political leadership. China confirmed to make steady progress in the implementation of policies with a focus on expanding domestic demand and reforming the economic structure. The two sides concurred to continue developing further mutually beneficial economic relations and advancing efforts towards regional and global economic development.
3. Mutually beneficial cooperation between Japan and China and its challenges

(1) Green economy

The two sides commended the advancement of their cooperation in the areas of energy conservation and environmental protection, and reaffirmed their commitment to enhancing their cooperation.
The two sides shared the view to make efforts on both ends towards the success of the Fifth Japan-China Comprehensive Energy Conservation and Environment Forum, which will be held in Tokyo in October. Furthermore, the two sides concurred to proactively promote cooperation on energy conservation and the environment, including cooperation on model projects in the areas of green economy and low carbon technology.
The two sides positively assessed the progress made in advancing their cooperation such as: cooperation on air, water, waste, and other environmental pollution countermeasures; so-called co-benefit approach simultaneously addressing greenhouse gas emissions and environmental pollution; measures to control the generation of yellow sand and ocean waste; and cooperation among cities regarding eco-towns. Furthermore, the two sides confirmed further promotion of these cooperative measures.
The Chinese side expressed high expectations for the Caofeidian Eco-Industrial Park in Tangshan City. The Japanese side decided to establish a Caofeidian Public-Private Study Group comprised of government bodies, the business community, and relevant organizations to facilitate the information sharing among relevant parties.

(2) Industry cooperation

The two sides shared the view to regularly hold a Japan-China Policy Dialogue on Distribution and Logistics , establish a Japan-China Distribution Dialogue, hold consultations at vice ministerial level among manufacturing and information industry-related agencies on a regular basis, and promote cooperation on information and communication. Furthermore, Japanese side requested to promote cooperation and the easing of regulations in the contents area.

(3) Financial cooperation

The two sides positively evaluated the strengthened partnership between the two countries' financial agencies on a bilateral and multilateral basis, and confirmed to engage in further cooperation for the stability and development of the financial market.
The two sides also commended the entry of their financial institutions in each others' markets and the progress made in expanding their scope of business. The Japanese side requested a flexible response towards Japanese banks regarding deposit-lending ratios, the listing of Japanese exchange-traded funds in the Shanghai Stock Exchange, the expansion of investment opportunities in China, the promotion of capital tie-ups through relaxing foreign equity limitation, and the opening of the third party liability auto insurance business to foreign companies.

(4) Improving the business environment

The Japanese side, in light of the requests from the Japanese business community, raised to the Chinese side a number of issues, including ensuring the transparency of the legal system, regulations on the export of rare earth, the accreditation system for self-innovation products, automobile-related policies, and the protection of intellectual property, and requested the improvement of the business environment in China. Furthermore, the two sides agreed to carry out a dialogue on information security products. Additionally, the Japanese side conveyed their concerns regarding the recurring labor disputes in China.
The two sides shared the view to promote custom cooperation. Both sides concurred to advance efforts towards revising the Japan-China Taxation Agreement.
The Chinese side welcomed the intention expressed by Japanese travel agencies operating in China that they will begin handling the trips to Japan by Chinese people before the end of this year.

(5) Strengthening cooperation in agricultural, forestry and fisheries industries

The two sides shared the view to cooperate on the management of bonito and tuna resources, joint study on foot-and-mouth disease, and measures to combat illegal logging. The Japanese side expressed renewed interest in the promotion of exports of Japanese agriculture, forestry and fisheries goods to China.
4. Global and regional cooperation and their challenges

(1) Global cooperation

The two sides recognized the importance of international economic cooperation through the G20 and shared the view to actively take part in the efforts leading up to the Seoul Summit. Both sides confirmed the importance of deterring protectionist moves and the importance of the early conclusion of the WTO Doha Round negotiations. The Japanese side expressed high expectations for China's early accession to the WTO Government Procurement Agreement with broad coverage. The two sides reaffirmed their commitment to cooperate for the success of the 10th Meeting of the Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD-COP10), which will be held in Japan in October 2010. Regarding climate change, the two sides engaged in a constructive exchange of views towards the success of the COP16. With regards to assistance for a third country, the two sides confirmed to advance bilateral dialogue.

(2) Cooperation of the Asia-Pacific region

The Japanese side requested that the negotiations on the Japan-China-ROK Trilateral Investment Agreement proceed in a constructive manner. Furthermore, the two sides shared the view to enhance the joint study by industry, government, and academic researchers for an FTA among Japan, China, and the ROK. Both countries confirmed their intention to actively promote regional financial cooperation. Additionally, they shared the view to actively work together toward the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Summit in November 2010, which will be convened in Japan.
5. Other issues

(1) Creation and signing of memorandums between governments and government authorities

The two sides welcomed, on this opportunity of the Third Japan-China High-Level Economic Dialogue, the conclusion and signing of six memorandums between governments and agencies in the areas of the environment and energy conservation, logistics and distribution, manufacturing and information industries, among others, as well as the conclusion of a memorandum between the private entities as outlined in the attached document [PDF]. These memorandums reflect the expansion of Japan-China economic relations on multiple fronts and the growing interdependence of the two economies.

(2) Next meeting

The two sides concurred to hold the Fourth Japan-China High-Level Economic Dialogue next year at a mutually convenient time in Tokyo.  Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, Overview of the Third Japan-China High-Level Economic Dialogue , Aug. 28, 2010.



_________


 What do these two versions of the same event reveal?  First,of course,is the language issue--both of these versions were produced in English and set free to roam on the Internet--and that suggests a targetting beyond local audiences.  Like the stories of the Samurai, his wife and the bandit, these versions are meant not merely for public consumption, but specifically for public consumption by the English speaking foreigner.   The Japanese version suggests power within a relationship in which it tends to be viewed as the more needy of the partners.  The Chinese version tends to strengthen the well managed campaign to depict the Chinese state as triumphantly entering the first rank of global powers.  Ironically, the Japanese version evidences the way on which the Chinese remain adept at playing both sides of the development field--managing their world image to suggest their first rank status while negotiating specifics deploying the full range of the rhetorical devices of the developing state.  That it continues to work remains a mystery--perhaps best understood as a function of need, that is the needs of China's trading partners.  Most interesting, perhaps, was the suggestion, at least on the Japanese side, that China and Japan would combine their forces in the upcoming meeting of the G-20 and WTO negotiations.  China has consistently battled what it perceives as moves toward protectionism (hurtful to its internal domestic development) on multiple fronts--from participating in the construction of the Santiago Principles for Sovereign Wealth Funds, to checking what it might view as the consequences of Western state policies designed to play well to their own domestic audiences in efforts to regulate themselves out of the recession that began in 2007.  That Japan shares some of these concerns makes it a useful ally against Europe and the United States in upcoming negotiations. Even better since the close relationship between Japan and the United States permits China greater entry into the thinking of both allies running up to the meetings--and thus permitting China a greater indirect influence in managing that relationship.
 
In efforts to try to understand the thrust and meaning of actions by two of the more vital states in East Asia it is sometimes useful to consider their approaches to fairly ordinary events for clues about perspective, approaches and understandings of the use and effects of institutional relationships.

Sunday, September 05, 2010

Institutionalizing China's Go Global (走出去战略) Policy: A Recap of China's Outbound Investment Rules

Like other developed states, the People's Republic of China encourages both inbound and outbound investment.  Unlike the oldest developed states, China can still exploit the propaganda of "development" to mask the extent to which it has achieved its status as a member of this exclusive group of nations occupying the first tier of power and influence.   That masking is a powerful tool in forging China's relationship which less powerful states, especially those still developing into which China is projecting its investment.  See, Larry Catá Backer, Courting Africa--21st Century China Africa Investment and Cooperation Forum, Law at the End of the Day, Aug. 7, 2010; Larry Catá Backer, China and Neo-Colonialism in Africa: A Warning from South Africa, Law at the End of the Day, Dec. 15, 2006.

But unlike Western developed states (and more like Japan), The Chinese state apparatus, under the leadership of the Communist Party (领导), has been developing a well coordinated and institutionalized program that seeks to direct Chinese outbound investment into channels that serve both the economize interests of public and private entrepreneurs and the overall interests of the state.  I have suggested its contours through the structuring of the Chinese sovereign wealth fund.  See Larry Catá Backer, Sovereign Investing in Times of Crisis: Global Regulation of Sovereign Wealth Funds, State Owned Enterprises and the Chinese Experience, Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems, Vol. 19(1):3-144 (2010).  

My research assistant Siyu Zai has produced a short description of China's current policies, procedures and regulation of outbound investment that begins to suggest the institutional contours of China's well coordinated approach to projections of economic (private) and political (public) power  in its through global economic markets with political actors. 
 
__________
China's Current Policy, Procedure, and Regulation on Outbound Investment
Siyu Zai

In the years 2004 and 2005, the China Development and Reform Committee, together with Import and Export Bank of China, issued two Notifications on the state’s support of major projects in outbound investment. In the Notifications, the two institutions addressed Chinese governments at all levels and state owned enterprises to support and facilitate financing for outbound investment. The Notifications provide that China Development and Reform Committee and Import and Export Bank of China will build a credit aid mechanism for outbound investment. Based on the nation’s policy, the Import and Export Bank of China will arrange finance that is specifically made for the purpose of supporting projects encouraged by the state. These special-purpose loans receive a favorable interest rate. Primarily, these special-purpose loans are for the following projects:

1. Investment projects on resources that can compensate China’s lack of resources;  
2. Productive projects or infrastructure projects that can facilitate the export of China’s technology, products, facility or the export of labor service;

3. Overseas research and development center program that can utilize international advanced technology, management experience, and professionals;

4. Merger and acquisition projects that can improve enterprises’ international competence and that can accelerate the exploration of international market.

Any corporation that is chartered in China is eligible to apply for these loans.

The Notifications also provide that the Development and Reform Committee guides and facilitates those outbound investments in order to achieve good economic and social effects. Likewise, the Import and Export Bank of China shall accelerate the review process for these projects. In addition, the Bank will also provide other services, such as cooperating with international financial organizations to put financial plan into practice. The Bank will further extend the length of maturity for loans made to strategic projects.

The two Notifications can be found at http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/wzly/jwtz/jwtzzn/t20050928_44059.htm and http://www.ndrc.gov.cn/zcfb/zcfbtz/zcfbtz2004/t20050613_7160.htm.

In year 2009, the Development and Reform Committee further issued another Notification on outbound investment. In the Notification, the Committee stated that, these years, Chinese enterprises apparently increased the volume of their outbound investment, under the guidance of the state’s “Go Global” policy. This Notification applies to investment projects that are approved by the Committee or the State Council, including outbound acquisition and overseas competitive bidding. The Notification requires Chinese enterprises deliver to the Committee, as well as other concerning governmental departments, informational reports on their investment projects. The informational reports shall provide all required information listed on the Committees’ website, www.ndrc.gov.cn. The Committee will issue a confirmation letter with seven days upon receiving an informational report. If the Committee discovers any substantial adverse factor related to the proposed investment project, the Committee will include a risk tip in the confirmation letter. With projects that have adverse factors, the Committee will exercise strict scrutiny and the enterprise shall act with caution. The Notification further provides that the Committee will circulate a notice of criticism for enterprises that violate the Notification. The Committee may further sanction on concerning departments and leaders for violating the Notification.

The 2009 Notification can be found at http://www.sdpc.gov.cn/zcfb/zcfbtz/2009tz/t20090619_286696.htm.

In 2005, the State Administration of Foreign Exchange issued a Notification on banks’ adjustment made to investing enterprises’ external guarantee with a financing nature. In the Notification, the State Administration of Foreign Exchange stated that, in order to support enterprises participating in international cooperation and to solve of problem of financing, under the Administrative Measures on Domestic Institutions’ External Guarantee, the Administration decided to further simplify the procedure that authorized bank for dealing in foreign exchange provides external guarantee to overseas subsidiaries of domestic enterprises.

The Notification issued by the State Administration of Foreign Exchange can be found at http://www.law-lib.com/law/law_view.asp?id=96619.

In addition, in 2007, China Insurance Regulation Commission, together with People’s Bank of China and the Administration of Foreign Exchange, provided an administrative measure to regulate Outbound Investment made by Insurance Fund. http://www.law-lib.com/law/law_view.asp?id=206909.

__________

The construction of a more sophisticated and well managed system for the coordination and direction of Chinese outbound investment is likely to produce a number of substantial benefits to the Chinese state.  These take two principal forms.  First, it serves as a laboratory for the development of Chinese approaches to economic regulation.  The contours of this approach is beginning to take form and can be roughly organized into three broad  categories.  One, overall economic policy is developed under the overall direction by the Party.  Two, the state apparatus (National People's Congress internally and specific ministries externally)  transforms these policy goals and directions into specific goals and programs and provides the mechanisms through which they might be attained.  Three, the productive sectors, both private and public sectors, are expected to conform their business decisions to these goals and objectives, as the principal structural constraints on their overall goal of maximizing the economic value of their activities (that is, of making profits for their entities and shareholders). 

Second, it permits the construction of a system of economic organization in which public and private goals can be merged within a free market framework.  The object is to provide a theoretical farmework that permits broad and specific interventions by the state in the ordering of economic priorities and values while retaining a framework of individual and institutional maximization within the value system and in step with the direction specified by the state.  What makes this interesting is that there are echoes of this movement in the West as well.  See, e.g., Larry Catá Backer, Values Economics and Theology: The Contribution of Catholic Social Thought and its Implications for Legal Regulatory Systems, 5(2) Economics, Management, and Financial Markets 5(2):17-56 (2010).But the different between Chinese and Western approaches is centered on the role of the state in determining values systems, and its authority to direct the specific direction of economic activity--things left to the private sector to a much greater extent in Western versions of this model.  See, Larry Catá Backer, Private Actors and Public Governance Beyond the State: The Multinational Corporation, the Financial Stability Board and the Global Governance Order (August 13, 2010) (forthcoming Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 17:-- (2011).